5 Best Leather Sofas: Luxury and Comfort

By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: April 21, 2021
Recliner Land is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Picture yourself in the most beautiful room you can imagine. Renaissance art hangs on the walls and you are drinking Evian out of a golden chalice. What are you sitting on? A fine leather sofa, of course! Leather sofas are the pinnacle of classy furniture, the perfect balance of style and function. Leather sofas are timeless in their appearance while also being comfortable enough for everyday use.

We compiled a list of the five best leather sofas you can buy online. We based our findings on several criteria, including the quality of the material, level of comfort, size, price, warranty, and durability of each sofa. As you will find out, there are a ton of great options that will suit any taste or budget.

Top 5 Leather Sofas Review 2021

1.

POLY & BARK Napa SofaEditor’s Choice

Features
  • Size: 88.5 x 38 x 34 inches
  • Seat depth: 24 inches
  • Seat height: 19 inches
  • Weight: 151.7 lbs.
  • Material: dyed Italian tanned leather; high density foam polyester filling; wooden legs
  • Warranty: 1 year

This beautiful leather sofa perfectly blends comfort and appearance. It was an easy pick for our Editor’s Choice because it is so difficult to find a reasonably priced leather sofa that is made with this level of quality and execution. The design is flawless, with a depth in the seat that makes lounging easy and gives room to spread out while not being bulky and cumbersome. Its sturdy feel is thanks to a corner-blocked wooden frame design, meaning this sofa will be durable and hold up through whatever life throws its way. Where this sofa impresses most is in its sophisticated look, but that does not mean it skimps on comfort. Each cushion is made with high-density foam and a polyester filling to add support, and all the seating surfaces are given a layer of feather down to add that extra bit of comfort. But the real star of the show is the dyed Italian tanned leather. Great quality leather is important because the scuffs and scratches that occur will enhance the color and character of each sofa, adding a vintage uniqueness to the natural sheen that develops beautifully over time. This sofa is proof that there is no replacement for high-quality material.

What we liked:

  • Great quality leather, elegant design.

What could be better:

  • Nothing!
Features
  • Size: 96 x 39 x 35 inches
  • Seat depth: 23 inches
  • Seat height: 19.5 inches
  • Weight: 156 lbs.
  • Material: top-grain leather on seating and arms rests; split grain leather on the sides and back
  • Warranty: 30 day free returns

Bigger really is better with this Hydeline sofa. A couch should be a comfortable oasis, and sometimes that means having a little extra room to stretch out. Coming in at 96in long, this 100% leather sofa can easily accommodate many people, making it great for families. The square track arms and solid wood legs are key design elements for durability, as is the kiln-dried solid wood frame with L-braced and glued corner blocks, which are the bones that keep this couch upright. This couch stands out with its high-quality construction and comfort, which is why we chose it as our Premium Pick. The straight lines of the seat back and arms give the whole couch a streamlined look that ensures the size will not overwhelm a room. The cushions are made with comfort in mind, stuffed with premium goose feathers and down, and set upon pocketed coils surrounded by 2.25 high resiliency foam. This makes for a cushion that seems firm at first but slowly eases into the perfect position over time, giving a sense of natural support. The couch will not blow you away with its looks, but it will impress with its top-grain genuine cinnamon brown leather, giving an understated appeal.

What we liked:

  • Great size and build, offers superior comfort.

What could be better:

  • More inviting appearance.
Features
  • Size: 56.3 x 33.9 x 35.4 inches
  • Seat depth: 20.86 inches
  • Seat height: 18.5 inches
  • Weight: 73 lbs.
  • Material: hardwood frame; beech wood legs; foam cushions; leather upholstery
  • Warranty: free returns for 30 days

Sometimes the best option is the most versatile. Thanks to its smaller dimensions and sleek design, this Rivet Cove loveseat sofa is a great option if you are looking for the perfect piece for a particular room. This piece’s mid-century modern design is a trendy, fashionable choice that relies on simplicity and clean lines to elevate the look while not sacrificing comfort. We love the timeless appeal that this couch offers. A hardwood frame sits atop beech wood legs, giving a sturdy foundation. Hand stitching is used throughout the upholstery to add a richness in texture, and the hand-tufted cushions and tapered wooden legs add a sense of warmth and charm. The foam cushions are reversible, adding to the versatility of the sofa, and they can be easily cleaned with a soft, dry cloth. This couch is also quite light, meaning you can easily mix and match in different rooms without breaking your back. Easy assembly and free returns for thirty days are just the icing on the cake. Compared to its counterparts, this loveseat lacks hand-crafted, artesian leather material, but this does not take away from the overall quality of the loveseat. The Rivet Cove Loveseat is our pick for Best Value, making it the perfect choice if you are in the market for a more affordable, smaller option for a leather sofa.

What we liked:

  • Affordable, compact.

What could be better:

  • Top quality material.
4.

Edloe Finch Finley SofaMost Spacious

Features
  • Size: 82 x 33 x 28 inches
  • Seat depth: 20 inches
  • Seat height: 18 inches
  • Weight: 128 lbs.
  • Material: Brazilian top grain leather; plush cotton and high-density foam
  • Warranty: 2 years

Edloe Finch is a brand that prides itself on expert craftsmanship and quality materials, and their Finely Sofa is just another example of their commitment to this promise. At first glance, the Finley grabs your attention with its unique style. The clean lines and chic materials make for an elegant, minimal appeal that fits perfectly within any design theme. And at only 82in, the Finley sofa is built to fit in any living space, no matter how cramped. The beautiful cognac brown color of the authentic Brazillian top grain leather will develop with age into a gorgeous vintage patina. Because the Finley is scaled down in size, it will limit the ability for some to be able to stretch out and enjoy a nap on the pillowy soft seat cushions. Certain design aspects make for tricky cleaning, as only the seat cushion can be removed, and the inability to remove the legs makes moving the sofa tougher. Though this is a small price to pay for the integrity of design and high-quality materials of the Finley. Edloe Finch offers a two year warranty for this particular piece, so you can bet that they have confidence in its craftsmanship and durability

What we liked:

  • Great quality materials, chic and stylish presentation.

What could be better:

  • Hard to clean and move.
Features
  • Size: 87 x 38 x 36 inches
  • Seat depth: 22 inches
  • Seat height: 20 inches
  • Weight: not specified
  • Material: top-grain leather on seating and arms rests; split grain leather on the sides and back
  • Warranty: 30 days free returns

A great option for nearly any living room, the Hydeline Elm looks like a two-seater but is built to fit a whole lot more. At first glance, the Elm is noteworthy for its slick and simple design, which is perfectly accentuated by the luxurious slate grey top grain leather seats and armrests. This sofa provides great size and a sturdy build, made from the kiln-dried solid wood frame with the L-braced and glued corner blocks that Hydeline puts in many of their products. The Elm is built with a no-sag spring base and sports foam padding throughout the sides and back. Specific design elements like the cushioned arm rail and pub back seat cushions boost the overall comfort, making this a perfect sofa couch to sink into and stay awhile. The Elm is not the flashiest of lookers, though its sleek, modern feel is a great fit for just about any interior design style. Whatever the Elm may lack in appearance is made up for in reliability and comfort, and with a thirty-day warranty and free premium white glove delivery service, there is no reason to second guess the Hydeline Elm as a great quality sofa well worth your money.

What we liked:

  • Durable quality and roominess.

What could be better:

  • Simplistic presentation.

Things to Consider

Buying a leather sofa online can be tricky. It’s always ideal to take a spin on the couch in real life before shelling out the cash, just to make sure that the sofa is comfortable and well built. This is impossible if you are buying online. There is nothing worse than ordering a sofa, waiting for it to arrive, and then finding out it looks nothing like it was supposed to, or that the cushions are hard as a rock. But do not fear, our buying guide will answer any lingering questions you may have and give advice about what to keep in mind when shopping for a sofa online.

Advantages of Leather Sofas

5 Best Leather Sofas: Luxury and Comfort

Nothing says timeless comfort like a leather sofa. They are simply the perfect mix of comfort, durability, and style. A sofa plays an important role in whatever room it is in, and the right sofa will be many things all at once. First, sofas are large, and it’s important that they look nice. Having an eyesore of a couch can ruin the design and overall aesthetic of a room. This is why leather sofas are so popular: they look amazing. Leather is a classic and understated material that is unique in that, as it ages and accumulates wear and tear, the appearance of the sofa is actually heightened, as opposed to fabric sofas that become tattered with age. Leather is versatile in its appearance as well as durable in its quality. There’s a reason we wear leather boots on our feet. It’s because leather is naturally waterproof, resistant to tearing and poking, and long-lasting.

Leather is also a comfortable material that offers support and structure while being pleasing to the touch. Its ability to change its shape without losing its integrity makes it a perfect material to use when upholstering furniture.

Features to Consider before you Buy a Leather Sofa

There are plenty of features to look for in a leather sofa. As there are so many diverse options to choose from, think about some of these features before buying to help narrow down your search. These features deal with dimensions, materials, and important warranty information, and will hopefully lead you in the right direction.

Size

How much space do you have to work with? This is a crucial question and will be important to refine your search. Sofas come in all shapes and sizes, from oversized sofa couches to smaller loveseats. Bigger sofas are great for living rooms, TV rooms, or any place where many people gather to socialize and relax. The Hydeline Dillon is a great option if you want to go big, as 96 inches of length will comfortably seat three adults, and can provide a great nap spot for most people who want to lay down. But what if you live in a condo downtown and are trying to make the most out of a relatively small space? Here is where you would seek out a loveseat or smaller sofa. Just because floor space is limited doesn’t mean your seating arrangements should be. And sofas like the Rivet Cove Mid-Century Modern Tufted Leather Loveseat Sofa are designed with small rooms in mind.

While you won’t be able to stretch out or seat a family of four, these sofa loveseats are great maximizers of space and are often lighter, so that they can be moved around easily to open up a room. They work well in offices or reading rooms, apartments, or anywhere else where space is at a premium.

Seat depth

Seat depth refers to the amount of space that you have to sit on, or how far the couch juts out. This is an important feature to keep in mind because seat depth is crucial for comfort. The average person needs between 21 and 24 inches of seat depth to sit comfortably.

Taller people have more room to work with, while shorter people risk their legs hanging off the edge of the couch if the seat depth is too high.
More seat depth means more room to use while on the couch. Think about seat depth like the difference between a twin and a full-size mattress. A shorter person can sleep comfortably on a twin, where a tall person’s feet might be hanging off the edge. The roles are reversed for sofas. Does your family have children? If so it may be better to go with a shallower couch like the Edloe Finch Finley Sofa to accommodate the little ones. If the height is not much of an issue, the Poly and Bark Napa Sofa is a great option, as the 24 inches of seat depth will give substantial seating space.

Seat height

Much like seat depth, seat height is an important dimension question that will change the level of comfort between sofas. A high seat back usually provides the most comfort, as there is more surface area to support the back, neck, and head of whoever is seated on the sofa. The higher the sat back the more a person can lean backward to find the sweet spot. Most sofas on the market will average between 17 and 18 inches, but the Hydeline Elm measures at 20 inches, making it a great option if you are looking to maximize comfort. Oversized sofas like the Hydeline Elm are modeled for comfort, but be aware that a higher seat back will mean an overall larger couch, which will take up more space.

Weight

5 Best Leather Sofas: Luxury and Comfort

The question of how much a sofa weighs is important for a number of reasons. Think of all the things that make a couch heavy: springs, cushion material, the wooden frame. These structural components are important for design integrity, but can at times become burdensome. Heavier sofas are usually larger and made with denser material. This is great for making a substantial piece of furniture and will signal that the couch is durable and resilient. Heavy couches are also often packed with more springs and stuffing that will boost comfort and give you more room for seating. But have you ever tried to move a really heavy sofa to another house? Talk about a headache! There are certain advantages to having a light sofa, the biggest being that it is easier to transport. Are you a college student or a renter? Think about going with a light option like the Rivet Cove Loveseat Sofa, in the event that you have to move it around a few times. On the other hand, if you are a homeowner looking to deck out a mancave or fill up a home theater, think about buying something heavy like the Hydeline Dillon so that you can ensure your choice is both durable and comfortable.

Material

If you’ve read this far, you must know what material you want for your new sofa: leather! But not all leather is the same. The range of quality for the material of your sofa will drastically impact the price. If you are buying a very expensive leather sofa, chances are it’s the quality of the leather that is causing the price to inflate. This is because good leather responds to wear and tear much differently than cheap leather.

High-quality leather will get better looking with age, whereas cheap leather will crack and even disintegrate.
Nothing can match the rich patina of fine Italian leather, and the Poly and Bark Napa sofa is the clear choice if quality material is most important to you. The Edloe Finch Finley sofa sports a high-quality Brazilian leather material that is also a great option.

Warranty

Most of the sofas on the market will come with some sort of warranty, but not all warranties are made the same. Usually, companies try to accommodate customers who are unhappy with their purchase by giving a window of time in which they can return the sofa free of charge. The average time for these warranties is thirty days, giving you about a month to decide if you love your new couch enough to keep it. For the more indecisive folks among us, think about the Edloe Finch Finley sofa, as the two-year warranty will allow you to get a feel for the sofa and will not punish you in the event that you change your mind. Other than warranties, certain sofas come with free delivery and pick up, and some sellers will even haul off your old couch free of charge.

FAQ

It is usually quite easy to assemble a leather sofa on your own. Companies have simplified the design of many of their products, making it possible to put together a new sofa in only a matter of minutes. Gone are the complex instruction manuals that require all sorts of tools and hardware. Many sofas only require screwing in legs by hand or using a wrench that they provide to affix a few pieces together.

High-quality leather upholstery can last for decades if it is properly maintained. The first step to proper leather maintenance is knowing what type of leather you are working with. If your sofa is made from pure anilines, then not much is required for cleaning and maintenance. Simply use a dry, soft cloth to remove debris, or if necessary, dampen the cloth with distilled water or an approved leather cleaner. Most leather sofas use protected leather, which holds up better to chemical cleaners, though it is important that any cleaners you use are free of detergents, dyes, or other harmful chemicals. Leather is sensitive, and cleaners with ammonia or alkalies can cause irreversible damage.

Our Verdict

The luxurious comfort of a leather sofa is the perfect fit for any living room. We loved rating these leather sofas, and while they all had merits, none had more than the Editor’s Pick, the Poly and Bark Napa sofa. The quality of fine Italian leather mixed with the elegance of its design makes the Napa simply unbeatable. Close by is our Premium Pick, the Hydeline Dillon, which impressed us with its roominess and commitment to comfort. For our Best Value pick, we landed on the Rivet Cove Mid-Century Modern Tufted Leather Loveseat Sofa, because the quality and versatility of this loveseat at this price is an absolute steal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *